The Financial Reporting Council has fined HW Fisher LLP and its lead auditor, Simon Mott-Cowan, over the 2020 audit of Liberty Commodities, a company within Sanjeev Gupta’s GFG Alliance. The regulator’s finding is blunt: a pervasive and fundamental lack of professional scepticism.
What the auditors missed
Liberty Commodities was a UK-registered trader of non-ferrous metals, semi-finished steel and steelmaking raw materials. Most of its sales were back-to-back: it bought from a supplier only after agreeing to sell the same goods onward. Follow the money and the catch appears. The model leaned heavily on supply chain finance from Greensill Capital UK and Wyelands Bank, the latter also part of the GFG Alliance.
The audit covered the year ended 31 March 2020. The FRC found serious breaches across seven areas, among them revenue recognition, asset derecognition, recoverability of trade debtors and intercompany balances, journal testing and going concern. The auditors, it said, did not adequately identify the risks of the company’s business model or assess its obligations under the finance agreements. Nor did they understand its arrangements with Greensill and Wyelands well enough to judge the effect on derecognition and going concern.
Andrew Twomey, the FRC’s acting deputy executive counsel, said: “This audit failed in its principal objective to obtain reasonable assurance about whether LCL’s financial statements as a whole were free from material misstatement.” The auditors, he added, “failed to comprehend and respond appropriately to obvious risks, including the risk of withdrawal of the Greensill financing facilities, despite the growing public scrutiny, as reported in the media at the time of the audit, on Greensill’s exposure to the GFG Alliance.”
The regulator drew one line, though. Its investigation did not suggest the lapses were “intentional, dishonest, deliberate or reckless.” On closer reading, that is no comfort to the profession, since Twomey stressed that failing to understand the entity and its environment “can undermine the ultimate performance of the audit as a whole.”
The penalties
HW Fisher was fined £200,000, reduced to £140,000 after it admitted the breaches, and the FRC formally declared that the 2020 audit report did not meet the relevant requirements. Mott-Cowan was fined £25,000, reduced to £17,500. Both fines were cut by 30% for admissions and early resolution. The FRC opened its probe in February 2022 and announced the sanctions on Tuesday.
Mott-Cowan voluntarily stopped his audit practice during the investigation. The FRC said he retired from all audit work at the end of 2025 and will not act again as a responsible individual or do audit work. HW Fisher, a London firm, merged with Sumer in October 2024 and kept its own brand. The sanctions predate that merger.
A group that unravelled
Liberty Commodities itself did not survive. On 31 March 2021, a unit of Citigroup, acting on Credit Suisse’s instruction, filed insolvency proceedings against it in a London court. Greensill Capital, exposed through its ties to Gupta’s group, collapsed that year, setting off a major financial and political scandal. The UK Insolvency Service banned its founder, Lex Greensill, from serving as a company director for nine years. In March 2025 PwC was fined over £4.5m for its audits of Wyelands Bank.
Gupta’s companies are also under investigation by the Serious Fraud Office, which says it is examining suspected fraud, fraudulent trading and money laundering linked to their financing arrangements with Greensill Capital UK.
Sources
- Liberty Steel Group
- HW Fisher fined by UK FRC over Liberty Commodities audit
- HW Fisher sanctioned over GFG Alliance audit lapses
Photo: Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)





