Markets, companies, property, jobs and trade

Home » Small Business Owners Face Harsh Collection on Pandemic Loans

Small Business Owners Face Harsh Collection on Pandemic Loans

By

–

Small Business Owners Face Harsh Collection on Pandemic Loans

A New Jersey manufacturer borrowed roughly $400,000 to survive COVID-19. This March, a Treasury collection contractor demanded $547,000 immediately, including $110,000 as a 30% delinquency penalty.

The letter from Coast Professional reached one of the company’s two owners at home. He asked to be called Nole.

“I didn’t sleep for a week when I got the notice. It was like, ‘How do I tell my wife?’” he said.

The two Economic Injury Disaster Loans carried a fixed 3.75% rate, a 30-year term and personal guarantees from both partners. Automatic withdrawals continued for 17 months following the initial deferment, according to Nole. When those debits stopped in mid-2024, neither owner noticed. The payment was about $2,000 a month, roughly 2% of their monthly bills.

Collection has since reached beyond the company. Officials withheld Nole’s federal tax refund for 2025 and began taking 15% from his pay at a second job. Credit bureaus also received notice of the delinquency.

A fight over notice

Nole does not deny stopping repayment. He disputes the government’s account of the warnings that followed.

The Small Business Administration says payment-demand letters went out in December 2024 and July 2025. Nole maintains that neither arrived and alleges that backdated documents appeared in his online EIDL account after Treasury received the case. The SBA did not answer questions about that particular allegation.

Spokesman Caitlin O’Dea said borrowers received “multiple written notices via direct mail, email and automated alerts through the SBA Loan Portal.” She said federal law generally obliges agencies to refer delinquent non-tax debts to Treasury, describing the referral as a statutory duty rather than a choice.

Other borrowers and their lawyers told Forbes a different story. Pennsylvania attorney John S. Benson said dozens among the hundreds he advised this year were contesting collections because of missing prior communication. He has had a few loans returned to the SBA and the 30% charge removed.

Dan Staeven of Frost Law in Annapolis, Maryland, reported seven such transfers back to the SBA. He blamed procedural failures and staffing losses in the EIDL servicing operation. O’Dea rejected the suggestion that the Department of Government Efficiency could alter SBA staffing and said a new Office of COVID-EIDL Services was created during a reorganization this summer.

Nole wants his original schedule restored, not the debt erased. “We’re not looking to run away from the loans. We just want the terms back. We want to go back to our payment plan and pay you.”

Personal guarantees outlive the pandemic

Businesses borrowing more than $25,000 through EIDL had to pledge company assets. For loans exceeding $200,000, every owner holding at least a 20% interest had to provide a personal guarantee.

For Kris, a 60-year-old construction-company owner near Dallas-Fort Worth, restoring installments would not solve the problem. She and her husband signed personally for $967,000. He died of cancer in 2024, and she says even a 30-year schedule without penalties is beyond the five-employee business.

CBE Group is seeking $1.4 million, including a 30% penalty. Kris fears losing her house and company, and is looking for a bankruptcy lawyer. She says a July call from the collector was her first contact about the debt in around three years. The SBA portal had described it as “uncollectible,” which she took to mean forgiveness or continued forbearance.

A third borrower, identified as River, disputes whether she should be personally liable at all. Her defunct nonprofit borrowed exactly $500,000. She says charity executives did not have to guarantee loans unless the amount exceeded $500,000, and that she signed no guarantee. CBE is pursuing her for $700,000, including interest and a 30% penalty. Her spouse’s tax refund has been withheld.

A vast portfolio meets a collection drive

The Congressional Research Service counted nearly 4 million business and nonprofit recipients of $378 billion in COVID-related EIDL lending from March 2020 through May 2022. It also distributed $27.5 billion in EIDL grants.

The separate Paycheck Protection Program supplied $799 billion in potentially forgivable loans. Some $763 billion, or 96% of the dollars distributed, has been forgiven. EIDL borrowing has no comparable forgiveness plan.

Repayment was repeatedly deferred under President Joe Biden, and hardship plans reduced required installments without cancelling interest or principal. In December 2024, the SBA charged off 369,588 delinquent accounts whose original balances exceeded $47 billion and carried no suspected or confirmed fraud. That accounting step did not extinguish what borrowers or their guarantors owed.

In April, the agency transferred more than 562,000 EIDL and PPP loans totaling $22 billion to Treasury, calling them “suspected fraudulent loans.” September brought an announcement that a record 870,000 borrowers associated with $39 billion in unpaid loans were ineligible for future SBA borrowing or programs, again under the label “suspected pandemic fraud.”

Fraud prosecutions are real. The Justice Department’s COVID-19 fraud enforcement director said the SBA inspector general’s work led to approximately 1,770 indictments through fiscal year 2025. Cases beginning in 2020 also produced 1,342 arrests; convictions totaled 1,168.

The estimates of fraudulent borrowing vary sharply. In 2023, the inspector general put potentially fraudulent EIDL loans at $136 billion and PPP funds at $64 billion. SBA management’s review placed total fraud across both programs at $36 billion, although the Government Accountability Office identified weaknesses in that process.

Todd A. Spodek, a New York lawyer whose clients have pleaded guilty to pandemic-loan fraud, drew a distinction between a crime and an unpaid debt. “A business that couldn’t repay isn’t a criminal. A paperwork error isn’t fraud. Fraud requires intent.”

Fewer routes to relief

At a September press conference in Kansas City, Missouri, the administration introduced “Operation No Doze,” pairing criminal enforcement with Treasury collections. The SBA said it would issue 30-day demands to suspected fraudulent PPP and COVID EIDL borrowers. Failure to pay in full could lead to referral to the Justice Department or Treasury.

Jason Milleisen, founder of Distressed Loan Advisors, estimates that a fourth of EIDL loans are in default. He warned that the end of deferments and reduced-payment plans would push distressed owners toward bankruptcy.

Some collection tools do not require a fraud conviction. Treasury’s powers include taking tax refunds, docking wages and withholding Social Security payments. Congress also extended the limitation period for collection lawsuits from five years to 10 years when pandemic-loan fraud is established.

Dwayne Thomas’s Portland event-lighting company, Greenlight Creative, lost 91% of its revenue when COVID struck. He used mortgage forbearance, cashed in a life-insurance policy, obtained two PPP loans totaling $94,000, since forgiven, and borrowed just under $500,000 through EIDL.

The business survived. It now has five full-time and 10 part-time employees, compared with four full-time and six part-time before COVID. Profits have not fully recovered, so Thomas pays the reduced minimum on his EIDL debt.

At 66, he had expected to finance retirement by selling the company. He now estimates it might bring $350,000, or at most half a million, rather than the couple of million dollars he once expected. “I couldn’t sell this business if my life depended on it,” he said.

Sources

Photo: i_am_jim (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Get breaking stories first on our Telegram channel.

More stories by

Most read

Markets & Wall Street

Transport & Aviation

Real Estate

Agriculture & Commodities